No matter how old I get, I’ll always love middle grade novels for their focus on coming-of-age character growth. And as an oboist in my youth and proud mama of a jazz trumpeter, if they also include musical instruments? Sold!! Muffled (2020) and Stifled (hot off the press), written by Jennifer Gennari and published by Beach Lane Books/Simon & Schuster, hit on both counts brilliantly. If you’re already a fan of Muffled, I guarantee you’ll adore the companion novel, moved from 5th to 6th grade and with Madge (BFF of Amelia, the original narrator) as the narrator this time around. But whether you’re new or already familiar, stay tuned for Jen’s insights!


Jen, I’m excited to welcome you to the Writers’ Rumpus blog! Muffled centers on highly noise sensitive, purple earmuff-wearing 5th grader Amelia, who settles on trombone – lest she be forced to spend that period in the wheezing counselor’s office – a fate she considers even worse. Stifled takes place in the tumultuous 6th grade year and centers on Amelia’s best friend, loud and outspoken Madge, the best trombone player of her year, and one of only four 6th grade musicians accepted into Jazz Notes (a really big deal, according to her). This novel focuses on how Madge becomes stifled as a result of struggling musically, largely due to self-imposed pressure from comparing herself to her long dead, French horn prodigy Mom. This in turn creates distance from Amelia, who is now focused on protecting the middle school school librarian’s job and the “Freedom to Boldly Read.”
Laura: Here is my first question: I loved the tender friendship that grows between Amelia and Madge in Muffled. The secondary characters are all interesting, too, and add greatly to the intriguing plot. Please explain how you developed your characters and plot for these two novels!
Jen: First, thank you for the kind words and for reading! Amelia came to me after experiencing a blizzard as a child, when all traffic stopped on my street and my suburb grew quiet, which I loved. I kept that memory as a story seed! Years later, I wondered what if quiet wasn’t only nice but a necessity? My husband is someone who needs quiet to recharge after a noisy day. I researched sound sensitivity and gradually shaped Amelia’s character. And Madge of course is Amelia’s opposite! Creating the rest of the band kids took many revisions. (I am definitely someone whose work improves over many multiple drafts!)
I love music but I’ve never played a brass instrument! Part of my inspiration for both books was my daughter Sarah and her best friend Carly. They played trombone from fifth grade through high school together, and their experiences (pressure, expectations) in jazz band inspired some of the scenes in Stifled. They are still friends today!

Best friends Carly Baxter and Sarah Shepherd, Jen’s daughter
Laura: In Stifled, you beautifully describe the growing pains that 6th graders everywhere experience, especially by highlighting how friendships shift and change as passions and maturity emerge. Other issues you cover are the way secrets are revealed, always at the worst possible times, plus how difficult becoming a lowly 6th grader is after being a top of the heap 5th grader. How in the world were you able to channel 5th and 6th grade experiences and mindsets so well?
Jen: Ask a children’s book author what age they feel at heart, and the answer often explains a lot! I remember being ten very well, and the struggles I had with a changing friendship in middle school. I was a shy and sensitive kid, and although I’m outgoing now, I pay attention to people’s emotions. I keep a journal and always carry a small notebook with me wherever I go to write down things I hear and see, something that strikes me, visually, an interaction, a bit of dialogue.
Laura: Tell us why you chose Boston as your setting for both novels! I failed to mention it in my intro paragraph, but I’m tickled that your novels are set there – a highly travel-able 25 miles from where I live. I especially appreciate how you feature the Boston Public Library and its lions in all their glory, as well as the T. Please also tell us about your decision to highlight book banning in our comparatively liberal state, a horror which helps Amelia find her voice. (Happily, in case any of our readers are unaware, Governor Healey recently signed a Freedom to Read law in Massachusetts! Thank you also to the Authors Guild members and other groups who helped make this law a reality.)

Jen: I lived in Newton for most of my childhood and briefly in Natick as an adult. I love taking the T! And the BPL has always been a magical place for me. After setting my first novel, My Mixed-Up Berry Blue Summer, in Vermont (where we moved when I was 15), I turned to the familiar landscape of Boston for my next book. In Stifled, after deciding what Madge would be stressed out about, I needed a subplot for Amelia, something to pull them apart. The topic of book banning was a natural for Amelia because she is such a big reader in Muffled! And although censorship has sadly grown in the last five years, so has resistance—and I am thrilled that at least four states have now passed freedom to read laws.

Jen’s beloved writing space in Vermont
Laura: Ooh- I would absolutely love to have a writing shed like that! You must dearly miss it.
Did you plan on writing a companion book when you wrote Muffled? If so, are more books in the pipeline or planned? If not, how did Stifled come about?
Jen: Writing Madge was so much fun, I knew almost immediately that she needed a story of her own! When the word “Stifled” came to me, it conjured the emotions that so many students feel when they transition from elementary to middle school. Yet it took time to decide on Madge’s backstory and to find the emotional core of the story. And, funny you should ask… I have been thinking about writing another Band Kid book, this time from a boy’s perspective. Stay tuned!
Laura: I can’t wait to read what you drum up! (Band Mom humor!) What do you hope readers will gain from reading these two books?
Jen: My wish is always that young people connect with stories that speak to them, whether it’s my book or someone else’s! I write for anyone struggling to fit in or wondering if they can make a difference in the world. My stories come from my passion for truth and justice and hope.
Laura: From your afterward, I learned that you work with agent Andrea Cascardi. How did you connect with her? What advice can you give other writers about how to find the right agent? What other writing tips can you share to pre-published authors?
Jen: Andrea and I have been working together since 2017, when I sent her a version of Muffled. I found her through reading book deal announcements in the free Publishers’ Weekly Children’s Bookshelf email. When we talked on the phone for the first time, we hit it off right away! Finding the right agent is about networking, doing research, and working on being the best writer you can be.

Jen’s current writing space – AKA (Laura’s comment) where the magic happens!
Laura: How can our Writers’ Rumpus readers connect with you?
Jen:

My website, jengennari.com has book links, newsletter signup form, and information for teachers and writers. I share book love and nature photos on instagram at @jennifergennari and jengennari.bsky.social. Stay in touch!
Photo credit: Alison Redlich Photography
Laura: Jen, it’s been a delight to interview you, and I eagerly await your next MG Band Kids novel. I’m also tickled pink (or should I say tickled brass in honor of the trombones that feature in your real life and in these two wonderful novels) that we met just TWO days before this post aired at the Newton, MA author festival!
Drumroll, please! Trombones, chime in, too! It’s time for the GIVEAWAY rules. One lucky reader (U.S. addresses only) will win both Muffled and Stifled (courtesy of Jen). All you need to do is leave a comment on this post. The winner will be randomly chosen on November 23, so please check back on that date to see if your name was chosen. We both wish good luck and happy reading, whether you win the giveaway or not!
